" very difficult for somebody to bring a claim against them on the basis of the content,” Delgado said. They enjoy broad legal protections, not only from creators if the content is taken down but also from any claimants who may want the content removed. Twitter, Instagram and YouTube did not immediately respond to requests for comment on whether Ye’s video violates their policies.īaker believes the video does breach Instagram’s terms of service because the threat “has been specifically made against Pete Davidson and disturbingly showing him being beheaded and buried.”īut social media companies are not legally obligated to take the material down, legal experts said. We also prohibit the glorification of violence.” Twitter’s rules state, “You may not threaten violence against an individual or a group of people. “This includes specific threats of physical harm as well as threats of theft, vandalism, and other financial harm.” ![]() “Serious threats of harm to public and personal safety aren’t allowed,” according to Instagram’s community guidelines. These social media companies have content policies, such as rules against posting violent content, and violations can result in getting kicked off the service. Ye uploaded the video on Instagram and then others shared it on different platforms, including Twitter and YouTube. For example, one of MTV’s popular programs was “ Celebrity Deathmatch,” in which claymation versions of popular celebrities would be decapitated and torn apart. ![]() There have been other parodies depicting violence against celebrities. “I think it’s more tame than many of the movies or video games that we watch.” I don’t think it’s like a call to arms to go out and attack Pete Davidson,” said Daniel Rozansky, an entertainment litigation partner at law firm Stubbs Alderton & Markiles. “It’s claymation, it’s his expression, there’s nothing realistic about it. " would go to helping to defeat any claim that this was meant to be taken seriously and consequently could constitute a true threat,” said Douglas Mirell, a 1st Amendment attorney with Greenberg Glusker.īut even without that disclaimer, the cartoonish nature of the video indicates it’s not a serious threat, legal experts said. “There certainly lacks the seriousness to the type of threat that these statutes tend to recognize,” said litigator William Delgado, a managing partner with DTO Law.Īt the end of the video, words flash across the screen referring to everyone living happily ever after except “Skete"- a nickname that Ye has used for Davidson - followed by “JK he’s fine.” But some attorneys said a claymation music video would not meet that threshold. #Latest music videos with lyrics code#Section 422 of the code makes it a crime to communicate a threat to do something that can result in great bodily injury or death to someone. carwash, pools of blood spilling from their heads.ĭespite the public reaction, which also included some voices of support for the singer, some legal experts did not see the music video as rising to the level of breaching California’s criminal code. The two men lay motionless on the sidewalk outside a South L.A. ![]() Social media are reshaping policing and conversations about violence ![]() The video released Wednesday triggered a widespread backlash online and is proving to be yet another test of what is acceptable on social media at a time when tech companies are facing mounting pressure to remove offensive material from their sites. In the music video for the song “Eazy,” Ye, who has been in a bitter divorce battle with his now ex-wife, Kim Kardashian, appeared to kidnap, bury and decapitate a clay figurine resembling her new lover, Pete Davidson. “I don’t even think this video should be allowed online,” he said. After several seconds of watching a claymation Ye hold a severed head and drag a wrapped-up body across the screen, Klein asked to stop the video. “I’m not sure you can threaten to kill someone even in a music video,” Klein said in his live “Off the Rails” YouTube show Wednesday, which included three hours of wide-ranging pop culture commentary. For him, the latest music video by the rapper formerly known as Kanye West might have gone too far. His legal battles have set precedents for commentary and fair use on the platform. YouTuber Ethan Klein is familiar with the boundaries for what you can post on social media.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |